What Sound Would You Go For

  Condom 09:55 17 May 2011

The problem of the quietness of electric cars is now being debated and it seems some regulation will be brought in so that they make some form of noise. What would you like to hear?

  knockin on 10:02 17 May 2011

Richard Wagner: The Ring

  wiz-king 10:25 17 May 2011

The sound of silence.

  Quickbeam 10:33 17 May 2011

As it would be from a digital file of sounds, you could choose anything from this Honda 6 to this Windows sounds

  Bingalau 10:38 17 May 2011

I watched a bit about this subject on TV this morning and thought then that a little bit of classical music might do the trick. Then again maybe not. Most vehicles owned by teenagers these days can be heard long before the engine anyway. Windows down, speakers full on and blasting out some type of head-banging music (sorry noise, because it's not music). So they wouldn't need to adjust to any new ruling about electric vehicles.

Maybe some sort of cheeky baker's boy whistle would do the trick. Remember when nearly all working men used to whistle on their way to work...

There's no doubt some noise indication is needed for the benefit of the blind etc.

Without noise it would be very eerie if one was stopped on the motorway after breaking down. Just feeling the wind of all the passing silent cars. Then the very nice AA man would probably say. "It doesn't sound too good to me, I will have to tow you to the nearest hearing aid station". Would they be equipped with a stethoscope to locate the problem area?

  Quickbeam 10:53 17 May 2011

Think how easy car repairs would become, just download a new mp3 track, and away you go...

  interzone55 11:26 17 May 2011

After I recent trip to London, where many Prius drivers tried to kill me by sneaking up at me, I thought that some kind of noise was required.

I decided that the most appropriate noise for an electric vehicle would be rattling milk bottles...

  Quickbeam 12:24 17 May 2011

"the most appropriate noise for an electric vehicle would be rattling milk bottles..." I wouldn't care to live adjacent to the M1 in 20 years time!

  Bingalau 12:53 17 May 2011

Maybe this inbuilt noise will be controlled by an on/off switch. So we could switch off when on motorways. But rattling milk bottles? Come on surely we can do better than that? How about rattling beer cans?

  wiz-king 13:16 17 May 2011

Up to 30mph - the laughing policeman. Over 30 the noise of the tyres would be enough.

  rdave13 15:58 17 May 2011

Something like this; Ferrari

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

iMac Pro review

Visual Trends 2018: This year’s must-know colour, design, branding & photography trends

iMac Pro review

Apple Music : comment obtenir 3 mois gratuits ?