Stoptober campaign

  [DELETED] 11:17 08 Sep 2012

I see the government is launching a 'Stop smoking for a month' campaign called 'Stoptober' across England and Wales commencing 1st October. The first mass campaign of this sort. The reasoning behind this is that if you can stop for a month you have a very strong chance of stopping for ever. The reason I and my wife stopped--on the same day- nearly 35 years ago was someone telling me that the body actually starts the recovery process from smoking damage just 8 hours after you stop! That kept us going and we never smoked again

  [DELETED] 12:10 08 Sep 2012

Nicotine more addictive than heroin yet smokers get very little help when compared to the hundreds of millions spent on drug addiction. There has been a bit of a campaign up here in Scotland on the millions spent on methadone with very little to show for it.

I too am an ex smoker, my smoking contributed to my throat cancer but the reason I gave up is I no longer could afford it. Good luck to all who try to give up in October but remember there are worse thing to be addicted to.

  [DELETED] 13:00 08 Sep 2012

The financial benefits from the tax take is far too much for sucessive governments to ever mount a seriously sucessful anti smoking campaign.

One might reasonably argue that the healthcare costs far outweigh the tax take, but the tax is now, whereas the costs are 10, 20, even 30 years away.

Just the usual short sightedness that one would expect.

I believe the phrase to describe this behavior is 'kicking the can down the road'.


  rickf 13:04 08 Sep 2012

Agree with WhiteTRuckman. Same with alcohol! This is just to show that they "care". They really do think we are stupid. Should ban it outright if they mean it and prosecution and sentencing for crimes induced by alcohol should be meaningfully severe to make a difference, same for illicit drugs

  Joseph Kerr 17:00 08 Sep 2012

"Worldwide (very round numbers) smoking accounts for 5 million shortened lives per year, alcohol 1 to 2 million. All other substances covered by the UN conventions - about 200,000."

But of course you are not ofering that as an example of how addictive anything is, which is a very difficult thing to establish indeed.

  [DELETED] 17:23 08 Sep 2012

Infinitesimally small numbers given the worlds population of 6,973,738,433 (World bank 2011, and given that the World Health Organisation estimates that there are one billion smokers worldwide. WHO Smoking. WHO Alcohol.

But I do think that there are certainly worse addictions as both drugs and drink can and do lead to crime which will mean far more people are affected.

Either you figures are wrong of you have missed off some zeros.

  [DELETED] 17:57 08 Sep 2012

I had a heart attack 21years and 7 days ago. The consultant said to me "You WILL give up smoking". When I came out of hospital a week later I had not smoked a cigarette and I have not since. The shock of having a heart attack must have made a big impression on me because I never had any withdrawal symptions. I had tried previously on a number of occasions to give up unsuccessfully. There was one occasion when I had the urge for a cigarette for a few seconds whilst driving my wife from hospital after her father had died. It was such a guilty feeling.

  daz60 18:01 08 Sep 2012

It seems that smokers are again the 'fall guy' for a Government initiative,if they were to campaign for a 'stop drinking for a month' maybe the bias would not be so obvious.

It seems that alcohol and its effects are more acceptable than smoking.They both cause personal damage yet the former is more socially,and possibly financially, damaging in respect to crime.

I do not smoke but i do like to drink so ,if only to prove to myself,after tonight for one month no drink.

Not excessively to drink,by the way.

  [DELETED] 18:19 08 Sep 2012

daz60. If I were to stop drinking for a month, the only difference would be in my weight and my wallet. I think that would apply to a lot of people too. I would probably lose a couple of pounds in weight anyway.

But that's sometimes what causes smokers to re-start smoking when they are trying to give it up. They put weight on quite rapidly because they start comfort eating.

  morddwyd 19:47 08 Sep 2012

There may be something in the "one month" figure.

The only reason I stopped, or was able to stop (50 years at 20+ a day)was because I picked up a hospital acquired infection which put me in bed for three weeks, during which time I did not smoke.

When I was well I thought I would be a fool to start again, nothing to do with will power, the craving had just lessened, though I missed it for about two years.

  carver 09:52 09 Sep 2012

Smoking causes harm to the people who use it, rarely does it cause immediate harm to other people directly and it's the worse craving I have ever had, even now over 8 months after stopping I still want a FAG.

Stop smoking for a month what a laugh, if that happened this government would be in a state of panic looking to make up for the lost revenue from the sale of tobacco products, people losing their jobs because nobody is buying tobacco, last thing they want.

Drinking on the other hand causes crime that is directly linked to drinking and what do they do, extend drinking hours.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Microsoft Surface Book 2 15in review

Illustrator Amy Grimes on how setting up her own eco-brand led to success with clients too

MacBook Pro keyboard issues and other problems

Test : l’enceinte connectée HomePod d’Apple