Sir James.

  Phil Ocifer 09:01 01 Oct 2012

I see Sir James Savile OBE is getting a posthumous revival.

Will these allegations get anywhere, or will they just become a platform for people to air their gravest suspicions?

Why did nobody come forward whilst he was alive?

  [DELETED] 20:02 01 Oct 2012

Jimmy Saville was pretty well known in the Royal Marines. He completed quite a few very hard physical tests and was always welcomed in the Corps wherever he went.

However, I was once at an occasion where because there were so many people to be fed we were all waiting in a queue at the Sergeants' Mess. He was an honorary member of the mess, but he also thought he could do as he liked and decided he wasn't going to wait in the queue. So he arrived at the head of it just as I was reaching it too and tried to get in front of me. I very politely told him that he might be allowed to get in front of other people but he was not going to get in front of me. He was then slowly edged backwards by others in the queue, until he was allowed in by a few wives who were also waiting. Maybe he was irresistible to women! He didn't seem a very likeable bloke to me though. But he brought a lot of publicity to the Corps.

  [DELETED] 00:31 02 Oct 2012

The man is now dead,I fail to see why it's deemed neccessary to have this story going round.Or is the CPS going to dig him up & summon him to court?JS alleged victims will still have their demons even if the stories are proved true.

  [DELETED] 09:48 02 Oct 2012

"JS alleged victims will still have their demons even if the stories are proved true."

Chegs ®™ is absolutely right. I know, my mother's behaviour still haunts me forty years later.

  Forum Editor 10:07 02 Oct 2012

Chegs ®™

"I fail to see why it's deemed neccessary to have this story going round."

That might probably be because you don't know what it feels like to have been sexually abused, or raped by an older person when you were very young. People who have those experiences never forget them, and they are often filled with suppressed rage. If the perpetrator is a very famous person it can deter a victim from coming forward whilst the person is alive - at least one of Saville's alleged victims has spoken about how she said nothing because she knew nobody would want to believe her because of Saville's fame for good works.

Each day seems to bring new revelations as victims decide to speak out, and now two of them have decided to reveal their identities. You don't do that if you are fabricating a story, you do it if you finally have courage enough to face the inevitable publicity. Cynics will talk of these women selling their stories, but think about how they must have felt over the years, every time they saw their attacker being lauded for his charitable works, and you might feel a degree of sympathy for them.

  [DELETED] 12:25 02 Oct 2012

wee eddie, I think we have to make it clear that there is a distinct difference between a teenage boy having sex with a 15 year old girl and a predatory older male who showed symptoms that he had an Oedupus Complex and preferred defenseless young girls to have sex with. I say his complex showed those signs because he was unable to have an intimate emotional relationship with a woman nearer his age group.

I was 17 when I met a girl of 15 (and she told me she was 16). The sex was consensual and no force was given. A mite different than what we're presented with by Mr 'how's about that then' (followed by silly gutteral sounds.

  Forum Editor 12:38 02 Oct 2012

"Presumably there will be a full and proper investigation of all claims, by appropriate authorities, before any conclusion is reached."

People will reach their conclusions, regardless. The difficulties with things like this are considerable. The alleged perpetrator is dead, so there can be no charges, no trial, no defence or prosecution evidence, no conviction and no formal sentencing. You can say what you like about a dead person because he or she has ceased to exist, and cannot object, refute a word or offer any defence.

What can happen is a form of setting straight as far as the public record is concerned. If enough convincing evidence comes to light (and it can only be verbal evidence) society at large can be informed that perhaps a person who was considered a national institution may have been a criminal. The work that Jimmy Saville did on behalf of charity is a fact, and that isn't going to change. What will certainly change now is the public's perception of him as being a thoroughly decent person. Accusations like the ones that have been made will be remembered, regardless of what happens in the future.

  Quickbeam 12:53 02 Oct 2012

"People will reach their conclusions, regardless."

As was the case in the barber's this morning, "I always knew he was odd", "There's no smoke without fire", " It doesn't surprise me at all" etc, etc, etc.

"Accusations like the ones that have been made will be remembered, regardless of what happens in the future." How true...

  [DELETED] 13:53 02 Oct 2012

I understand from one report that other older male celebrities entered into his sordid world in his dressing room.

I hope all the people who condoned his sexual depravities feel thoroughly ashamed of themselves.

  [DELETED] 13:54 02 Oct 2012


"Accusations like the ones that have been made will be remembered, regardless of what happens in the future."

Which is exactly how the gutter press operates, make lurid accusations, retract the story and pay libel charges if necessary, but the story is always out there and dirt sticks...

  [DELETED] 14:59 02 Oct 2012

I did also say these alleged victims will still have their demons,and all the media attention directed towards JS & these victims will do little towards the victims laying these demons to rest.I have my own demons,I'm presently recieving physcoanalysis(unsure of spelling)for these & after every visit to the analyst I have nightmares for the rest of the week.One of my nightmares reminds me of a personal tragedy from almost 20yrs ago & I'd managed to live with this without the nightmares for the past ten years,the nightmares only returned after talking about this tragedy with the analyst.This media storm about JS will not give his alleged victims anything but refreshed memories of their traumas.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Microsoft Surface Book 2 15in review

Iglooghost's hyper new music video gives a mutant take on Monument Valley

The best Amazon Prime Day Apple deals 2018

Comment ajouter de la musique à une présentation Google Slides ?