Poppy Sellers banned

  BT 08:56 19 Sep 2011

This is going around on Facebook this morning. Don't know how true it is but its a scandal if it is.

*The Royal British Legion are not selling poppies in certain areas on Nov 11 this year. *This is because some minorities say that it will upset them. The poppy is a symbol of reverence for our fallen heroes of all the wars the BRITISH military have fought in. BRITAIN STAND UP AND SAY 'WE WANT THE POPPY SOLD EVERY WHERE IN THE UK'. THIS IS OUR RIGHT TO REVERE OUR FALLEN.. PLEASE RE-POST**

Poppy sellers have also been banned from some areas of Birmingham

Poppy Sellers banned in Birmingham

  Strawballs 09:04 19 Sep 2011

I asked for a link to the original story and got ignored

  interzone55 09:58 19 Sep 2011

This is a typical Facebook reaction.

Many cities, Birmingham included, have banned collections in shopping areas to stop the kind of Charity Muggers (Chuggers) I mentioned in a thread a while ago.

Unfortunately this has the unwanted side effect of preventing Poppy sales.

In Birmingham's case they've allowed Poppy sellers to carry on as normal, exempting them from the ban. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-birmingham-14922433

Lesson to be learnt from this, don't rely on Social Media as your only source of news

  Cymro. 11:18 19 Sep 2011

People in this country had better understand and start to accept that we are a multicultural nation and will only become even more so as the years go by. Who is it that is suppose to have made such a ban? I assume it was the local authority. They have been voted in to represent everyone, all creeds and religion. If the majority of the electorate don`t like the way things are run, the just vote them out of office next time.

  bremner 11:23 19 Sep 2011


Why are you linking this to multiculturalism when no such link exists.

The council had a rule that only two charities could collect in a street at the same time. The Anthony Nolan Trust and Shelter were already permitted.

Shelter have kindly dropped there collection so teh Poppy sales could go ahead.

  Aitchbee 11:25 19 Sep 2011

You can grow your own poppy plants (flowers) from seeds if you want to.I would buy poppy seeds for charity...no problem. £5 for 1914 seeds would be ok.

  Joseph Kerr 11:29 19 Sep 2011

Bremner, the link was made by the facebookers mentioned in the OP.

  Cymro. 11:32 19 Sep 2011

Bremner "Why are you linking this to multiculturalism when no such link exists" So what parts of the City and who were the people objecting? You say that Shelter have kindly dropped there collection so that Poppy sales could go ahead. So no problem there then? Mind you I would sooner support Shelter than the Poppy Appeal.

  interzone55 11:49 19 Sep 2011


Read mine & Bremner's posts again - it's nothing at all to do with objections against poppy selling, but general objections against the shear number of charities trying to collect in our city centres, often quite agressively. So limits have been placed on the number of charities who can collect at any one time.

The is no conspiracy here, or racial overtones...

  Cymro. 12:30 19 Sep 2011

alan14 "There is no conspiracy here, or racial overtones"

So whats all the scandal that BT was on about in his opening post then?

  bremner 12:49 19 Sep 2011

The scandal is simply FB stirring.

There is a story that councils have rules around charity collections and it suits certain individuals and groups to turn that into a race issue to suit their own agendas.

Right minded people see this and treat it with the contempt it deserves.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Honor 9 Lite review

How Social Media has Propelled Political Graphic Design and Art in the Last Decade

The best kids apps for iPhone & iPad 2018

HomePod d’Apple : date de sortie, prix et fiche technique