Pilot benefit scheme failing some recipients

  TopCat® 17:55 12 Mar 2013

This pilot scheme, introduced by the government over the last few months, has led to some recipients getting into arrears with their rental payments. Paying the benefit this way has seen a higher percentage rise in several areas where the scheme is being trialled.

Having the money in their own hands has led to some using it for other purposes, which in turn has seen a dramatic rise in arrears of rent.

What are your views on this - should the government revert to the status quo quickly or continue on with this scheme? TC.

  Aitchbee 18:22 12 Mar 2013

This pilot scheme will ensure that the queues at your local housing office, will get longer and longer.

There will also be a higher risk of crime, due to this crazy pilot scheme.

  john bunyan 18:22 12 Mar 2013

In theory the new scheme puts responsibility and dignity to the recipient. In practise, as you say, some succumb to the temptation to spend it on other things, leading to landlords losing out, and at the extreme, more evictions. Maybe the scheme could be flexible such that if payments are made regularly it goes as planned, but if there were a default, it would revert to the payment going straight to the landlord.

  fourm member 18:23 12 Mar 2013

Tricky one.

Obviously, getting into arrears can cause lots of problems but the point is that, those of us not living on benefits, have to manage our money.

If you don't try and get people into the real world then it seems to me you are encouraging them to become more and more reliant on the state.

Of course, you could argue that the government doesn't rely on us to pay our income tax by letting us have our wages.

The answer may be to let people opt to have their housing costs paid directly if they don't think they can cope or encourage them to set up a direct debit so the housing is paid the instant the benefit arrives.

  wiz-king 18:24 12 Mar 2013

Carry on - it would be easier and less costly to pay all benefits into a bank account belonging to a individual and let them decide who to spend it. For the ones who cannot cope then the bank account should be administered by the local council or other body under a deed of trust.

  lotvic 18:48 12 Mar 2013

wiz-king, "For the ones who cannot cope then the bank account should be administered by the local council or other body under a deed of trust"

how would that make sense? surely cheaper to pay it straight to landlord - if landlord is willing to have tenants that can't cope or are irresponsible....

  Al94 19:03 12 Mar 2013

Wouldn't have taken much in the way of brains to predict this would be the likely outcome - oh wait - civil servants - that explains it!

Fourm members idea wont work, they will still spend on other things and the direct debits won't be paid.

Maybe a fast track eviction would have been the answer.

  carver 19:34 12 Mar 2013

Well what a surprise, who could foresee that people who do not have enough money to live would use a little bit extra to pay for things like gas or electric or even food.

It's no good saying that they should learn to manage their money, they don't have enough in the first place.

The best part is the people who think up these stupid ideas wouldn't know how to survive on the money a lot of these people get every week.

You do realise that some of these people do not even have bank accounts in the first place

  fourm member 19:56 12 Mar 2013


You're taking a very limited view of a limited group of people.

There are a great many people who don't have enough money but don't get any benefits. Those people have to manage their own limited resources.

  lotvic 20:34 12 Mar 2013

fourm member, Oh right, that's why PayDay loans are so popular then.

  carver 08:00 13 Mar 2013

fourm member why are you addressing me directly, you do not know how these people live/ survive you do not have children to feed/ clothe keep warm.

These are people who some times through no fault of their own do not have enough money to live and they are faced with a choice, feed their children and keep them warm or pay the rent, sometimes watching your children go hungry is not funny.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Dell XPS 13 9370 (2018) review

Creative studio Omnibus' brand identity for We Said Enough, a non-profit against sexual misconduct

What to ask Siri on the HomePod

Meilleurs VPN (2018)