I was wondering, FE.....

  ade.h 19:10 16 Mar 2006

With that thread we had a while back in which you asked for some suggestions for a possible new forum feature, I wondered if your backroom boffins had anything in the pipeline for the future.

  Forum Editor 19:20 16 Mar 2006

We're extremely busy with a couple of other projects just now, and we're not planning any changes in the near future. We think we'll let the forum run as it is for a while.

  ade.h 19:37 16 Mar 2006

Fair point; if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

  sunny staines 12:20 17 Mar 2006

an update forum for updates to drivers, programs etc. just an idea.

  wolfie3000 21:39 17 Mar 2006

Games forum???? sorry.

  bremner 22:39 17 Mar 2006

there was a game forum a while back - went the way of the Saber Toothed Tiger and Wooley Mammooth

  VoG II 22:43 17 Mar 2006

A Microsoft Office forum? In the far future!

  ade.h 23:18 17 Mar 2006

An Excel forum which VoG could staff full-time!

(Just kidding, VoG; we wouldn't force that on you!)

  DrScott 17:20 18 Mar 2006

A PC builders forum - I think it'd have the same kind of popularity as the webdesign forum. Only trouble is PCA as a magazine doesn't really focus on components that much (hence why I get into trouble by my other half for buying yet another computer magazine every month!).

  WhiteTruckMan 19:58 19 Mar 2006

I would be tempted to split the helproom in two. one for hardware issues and another for software.


  Forum Editor 20:51 19 Mar 2006

for over five years now, and one thing that has become apparent is the folly of splitting the whole thing into too many parts.

We previously ran a games forum, but it wasn't successful. We had a 'Lounge' area for a time, and that will live in our memories as an example of what not to do if you want a peaceful, harmonious community. Along the way there have been all kinds of diversions - at one point we had a private forum where an invited group of people offered suggestions as to which direction we should take. A few people from that group are still with us, and I'm sure they would agree that - pleasant as it was - the committee method wasn't really a success. Everyone (including me) had their pet ideas, and we weren't ever going to agree on everything - or even most things.

From my point of view the most successful venture ever was when we got Sun Microsystems to commission us to carry out a consumer survey on Star Office click here

We ran a special forum for a fairly large group of invited forum members. Everyone was provided with a copy of Star Office, and I set a structured series of tasks over a seven day (I think it was) period. As each task was completed we all discussed the pros and cons in the special forum, and at the end of it all Guy Dixon and I wrote a feature for the magazine. Sun systems were extremely impressed with the way we all worked at the project, and they were delighted with the feedback we provided. We thoroughly enjoyed the process, and I think I can say that most of the participants did, too. I would certainly like to do something like it again, and I'm going to badger our new magazine editor about it.

Over the years we've experimented with different areas, and no doubt we'll do so again at some point, but not in the foreseeable future. I say 'foresseable' advisedly, because of course circumstances can change quite quickly. We'll probably run a dedicated area for Vista when it launches - it all depends on what kind of a reaction it gets in the market.

To be honest, I think we can handle PC building issues within the present structure - we don't get that many self-build questions when compared to some other topics. Much the same applies to MS Office I think, although it's true that we do see a lot of Excel/Word threads in the Helproom.

It hasn't been that long since we redesigned the site, and there are still some tweaks we intend to carry out when time permits. Rest assured that we're not just sitting on our hands - we know what it's like when you have a brainwave, you want to see it translated into action, but it isn't that simple. We're conscious of wanting to fulfil the expectations of the majority, rather than trying to cater to lots of minority interests; you certainly can't easily do both under one roof.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Honor 9 Lite review

How Social Media has Propelled Political Graphic Design and Art in the Last Decade

The best kids apps for iPhone & iPad 2018

HomePod d’Apple : date de sortie, prix et fiche technique