Does anyone

  Al94 22:58 23 Dec 2012

find Sarah Millican remotely amusing?

  Forum Editor 23:05 23 Dec 2012

I imagine that lots of people do.

What's the point of this thread?

  Al94 00:05 24 Dec 2012

The point of the thread was to make an enquiry of those here. She was on BBC at the time of posting, my wife and I find her voice irritatingly whiny, she, to us, is repetitively unfunny and obviously scripted. Before someone suggests the obvious, yes we did switch her off after again failing to see any talent.

  pavvi 01:12 24 Dec 2012

i find her mildly amusing but not laugh out loud funny- much better in my opinion than the professional troll that is Frankie Boyle!

  Forum Editor 12:02 24 Dec 2012

"They do television where their best material has to be delivered in a few minutes and then their full live shows get an audience that expects the same rate of laughs for a couple of hours."

That's part of the problem. It's made worse by the fact that a joke told on TV probably can't be used again for live audiences - most of them will have heard it. It means that there's a constant need for fresh stuff, and a lot of it will be mediocre at best. It's the reason that a lot of today's comedians appear to concentrate on playing the fool, rather than on good material. They seem to think that behaving outrageously and swearing on stage is enough - and for a lot of audiences it seems to be just that. They sit there, rolling with laughter at almost every inane remark they hear.

I have been a great fan of QI, but there are certain participants who set my teeth on edge - shouting and cavorting as if that's what comedy is about. The northener with long black hair is a case in point.

  spuds 12:40 24 Dec 2012

Yesterday evenings program appeared to be based on a Mrs Merton (Caroline Aherne)chat and scripted style venture?.

The other week there was a television show that went on for well over an hour, which appeared to be 'straight-off the cuff' and she was brilliant.

A bit like Mrs Brown's Boys (Brendan O'Carroll), you either hate it or like it?.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Xiaomi Mi 9 review

Apple has upgraded the iMac to make it twice as fast – and given the iMac Pro a quiet bump too

New iMac 2019 launch: Release date, price, features & specs

iMac 2019 : date de sortie, prix et fiche technique