AV Explained

  zzzz999 05:56 05 May 2011


This makes it clear for me

  Quickbeam 08:17 05 May 2011

Clear as chilled beer.

  canarieslover 09:59 05 May 2011

Best explanation that I've seen!!!

  johndrew 11:39 05 May 2011

Probably works when deciding on the winners of track events in the Olympics as well?? :-))

  OTT_B 12:46 05 May 2011

Can anyone post a direct link? Work firewall is blocking it!

  Quickbeam 13:05 05 May 2011
  Joseph Kerr 16:55 05 May 2011

Is it just the one page or am I missing something? I know how AV goes after that point (I think), but that page doesn't actually tell you.

  lotvic 20:17 05 May 2011

Joseph Kerr, One page, Nothing complicated - 10 people voting the FPTP way (not AV):

7 want to go to various pubs, 3 (30%) want to go to coffee shop. FPTP is coffee shop (3 people) so 7 (70%) don't get what they want.

It illustrates why FPTP is not fair.

  Woolwell 20:40 05 May 2011

The cartoon is actually misleading. The cartoon assumes that all the pubs are the same. In politics the same situation would be 4 politicians from one party (beer) and 1 from the other (coffee).

  Joseph Kerr 23:24 05 May 2011

lotvic, woolwell makes my point in a roundabout way.

it does indeed explain why fptp is not fair, but it does not go on to say that if two of those who originally wanted coffee then went for the Kings Head, the Lion or the Castle, that pub would then have 50% of the vote, so it would be the winner.

My points being that A) the page did not elaborate on how AV works and, B) the pubs are not the same.

  Joseph Kerr 23:32 05 May 2011

I just noticed my explanation of AV above is flawed.

However, the pubs are not the same and the illustration falls short of explaining that and the process in general.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Best Amazon Echo: What’s the best Alexa speaker?

Kano Computer Kit Complete review: A fun DIY 'laptop' that teaches kids to code

Best pro photo editors for Mac 2018

TV & streaming : comment regarder les Jeux olympiques d’hiver 2018 ?