Hot Topics

Aluminium Tube - Reduction of weight.

  flycatcher1 19:11 08 Mar 2014

I am trying to reduce the weight of an aluminium tube, 3mm thick, 4.5 inches in diameter and 4.4 metres long. It is necessary that the tube will not twist or bend and my first thoughts are to bore innumerable holes or make slits.

The tube is for a Conservatory sunshade, the last one was wooden and lasted 25 years but I hope that this one will see me out. I am 84 and can easily lift the tube but would prefer to reduce the weight.

Any help would be appreciated.

  spuds 10:05 10 Mar 2014

Does it have to be aluminium?.

I have used various thin walled lightweight materials, usually obtained from stockists of items like kitchen, furniture, roller blind fittings.

  bumpkin 13:15 10 Mar 2014

Sounds like an awful lot of drilling to make any noticeable difference. You say that the original was wood, obviously I have not seen your setup but would a length of wooden handrail do the job.

  namtas 18:45 10 Mar 2014

To limit the risk of breakage due to bending, place the holes working from both ends, up to around one third distance from the end, assuming that your rod is end supported only in which case the maximum bending stress are concentrated at the centre of the bar when under load and the stress proportionally decrease from the centers and becoming zero at the any support point.

  flycatcher1 19:57 10 Mar 2014

spuds The device is just a very large roller blind which is put up in the Spring and taken down in the Autumn. The original was constructed like a 20s model aircraft fuselage.14ftX 4.5 inches. It was strong and light and rigid after all those years it needed replacing and I could not face all the woodwork so that is why I went for aluminium. I did look at other materials but this was the only one that has the correct characteristics - my only worry is the weight. Tomorrow I will try to establish the actual weight difference using the bathroom scales.

bumpkin The wooden rail would be far too heavy hence the "fuselage" construction.

namtas Thank you for that information, it will come in useful if weight reduction becomes necessary.

I appreciate all the comments.

  Aitchbee 21:46 12 Mar 2014

... just seen on TV tonight, a space-station astronaut, who was demonstrating the use of a small rotating hand crank-lever to initiate an experiment for the camera ... it [the lever] was full of big drilled-out-holes to minimise it's weight to get it into orbit ... less fuel required.

  bumpkin 22:29 12 Mar 2014

Aitchbee, odd as it my seem the correct sized holes drilled in the right places can actually make a steel beam stronger hence the construction used in steel bridges etc, it is to do with the distribution of stresses as I recall from my years at Tech College. In OP,s case if it only needs lifting up and taking down once a year I would get some assistance rather than start drilling holes in it.

  Aitchbee 22:34 12 Mar 2014

bumpkin - not unless the OP is thinkin' of building an orbital Space-Conservatory in the near future :o)

  flycatcher1 19:02 27 Mar 2014

The project is now complete. I took namtas's advice and removed 32 X 10"X 1" pieces leaving about 20" clear at each end and in the middle and spaced the slots evenly. About 13% reduction in weight which I thought was worth it. In the end I think that I could have cut more slots and still maintained the required strength.

Yesterday my two tame professional engineers admired the work (with tongue in cheek) and put it up in two shakes. Works a charm, I should have done it 24 years ago.

  flycatcher1 15:59 28 Mar 2014

wiz-king I have put a note in my diary, if it is OK in 2039 I will let you know.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Resident Evil 3 review

Online portfolios: how to get your work out there while staying in

Apple 'to drop support for Apple Watch Series 2'

Les meilleurs gadgets high-tech pour voitures (2020)