14 year old guitarist

  Al94 08:59 23 May 2013

Pretty impressive stuff from this girl Tina S

  Quickbeam 10:57 23 May 2013

Very skillfull, very '70s.

  Forum Editor 12:44 23 May 2013

There are hundreds of these young guitarists, and - technically - they are very good. Some of them are, like this girl, absolutely brilliant. Unfortunately that's as far as it goes with most of them - their playing lacks any sense of feeling, and it's easy to spot. They can copy, but they can't innovate.

Occasionally one of them breaks through as a talent, but it's a very rare occurrence.

  al's left peg 16:28 23 May 2013

I agree with the FE on this one. A good few years back we had a young kid up here who was called Thomas Mcrocklin and he was exceptional as a young lad. He went on to play in a band called bad4good formed by Steve Vai, but sort of disappeared from the scene after a while.

The youngsters that play so well when they are really young end up getting caught up with other players developing as they age and become just one of many good guitarists, rather than an exceptional one as a youngster..

  Blackhat 18:10 23 May 2013

I was a guitarist, played in bands from the age of 16, self taught. Hung up all instruments following the 5th demise of bands that I had formed, each due to the death of a member. A long story for another time.

The girl shows absolutely no enthusiasm and is what I would call a ‘Technical player’. Very capable of learning by book or dvd but I doubt could hold her own improvising during a jam.

  Quickbeam 18:32 23 May 2013

I was going to say similar to the FE, but didn't as I'm only a basic bassist. There is a lack of pasion despite the technical skill.

  al's left peg 19:10 23 May 2013

I am a bedroom rocker. I have three guitars, a Stratocaster, Telecaster and Takamine acoustic.

  Aitchbee 20:30 23 May 2013

I used to have an old guitar [... that's all I could afford ], and used to know all the chords and played mostly rhythm when I got up to play, 'under the lights' as I didn't want to do anythin' fancy like make it [my guitar] 'cry' or 'sing'.

  Fruit Bat /\0/\ 22:12 23 May 2013

Aitchbee you must be a Sultan then :0)

  Aitchbee 22:30 23 May 2013

FruitBat ... well-spotted ;o]

  Forum Editor 01:20 24 May 2013


"Are you a Guitarist then FE??"

I'm a guitar player. I played in a band for three years when I was much younger; now I just play to amuse myself. I have been playing guitars for a very long time, I have a few of them around the house, and I pick one up when the mood takes me.

It would be immodest of me to say I'm a good guitar player. I'm an OK player, but I sure as anything know what a good one sounds like.

As for your remark that "God, you lot talk a lot of bullshit on this forum." that's an offensive remark. In your opinion this girl is "amazing", and on one level - that of her technical skill - she is certainly impressive. Of itself that doesn't equate to real talent as a musician however. She's young - maybe the personal flair will come later. In the meantime my opinion stands, and I certainly wouldn't be rude enough to say that you're talking a load of anything.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

iMac Pro review

25 book design and illustration tips

iMac Pro review

Idées cadeaux pour geeks et tech addicts