Which Video Capture format AVI / DV or MPEG ?

  Tinkey Winkey 20:26 03 Jan 2005
Locked

I want to transfer my Camcorder tapes to DVD.

I'm using Pinnacle Studio 9SE and comparing it with Intervideos WinDvd Creator 2 Platinum.

I don't want to edit the videos just make them into DVDs !

Which format is best for capture:
MPEG (High Quality DVD )or
DV

Both have a max resolution of 720x576 pixels.

Or doesn't it matter - will the final DVD quality be the same ?

  woodchip 20:28 03 Jan 2005

For quality AVI

For compression Mpeg

  Tinkey Winkey 20:41 03 Jan 2005

As the AVI has to be converted to MPEG2 DVD wouldn't there be more of a loss in quality than if you just converted the "MPEG" capture format to MPEG2 DVD ?

  john-232317 21:03 03 Jan 2005

I always capture with MPEG2 ;-) and had no problems with quality.

  rickf 21:50 03 Jan 2005

Always MPEG2 for me. no probs.

  Tinkey Winkey 19:28 04 Jan 2005

Thank you for your replies.

I have burnt 2 small clips to 2 DVDs.

One was video captured as an AVI and the other was in 'MPEG'.

Comparing them both I would say that the MPEG Capture produced a slightly sharper and brighter final picture than the AVI.

  GroupFC 21:56 04 Jan 2005

For reference

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

AMD Radeon Adrenalin release date, new features, compatible graphics cards

Print designer Kelly Anna on confident mark making & modern femininity

New iMac Pro release date, UK price & specs rumours

Comment créer, utiliser et supprimer son compte Facebook ?