System File Check

  [email protected] 15:37 26 Nov 2008

WinXP Home.
What's the difference, if any, between running sfc /scannow from the Run box and running Disc Check from the Drive\Properties\Tools tab?

  anniesboy68 15:43 26 Nov 2008

system file checker checks the file system,i.e. makes sure all the files of the operating system are correct. Check from the Drive\Properties\Tools tab....checks the disk for errors...or so I believe.AB68

  [email protected] 15:46 26 Nov 2008

Hi. I thought so too but I happened to notice the latter saying it was "checking files"?
The 2nd option of Disc Check does the drive surface I know.
Just wondered, like you do ;-)

  anniesboy68 19:50 26 Nov 2008

I thought you ran sfc /scannow from the command prompt?

  [email protected] 20:12 26 Nov 2008

Yes, you can, but I think it's the same as running it from the Run box.

  skidzy 22:18 26 Nov 2008

Chkdsk will verify and repair (optional) the integrity of the file system on any chosen volume.

The System File Checker will check system files and verify their integrity, replacing any files with which it finds a problem.

  DieSse 23:42 26 Nov 2008

"....I happened to notice the latter saying it was "checking files"?"

It's just checking the files are valid and readable. Not checking their contents are correct, as SFC does.

So you could replace a system file with a different file - Disk Cech would consider it OK (still a valid file, and readable) - SFC would tell you it's not the correct contents for that file name.

  woodchip 00:10 27 Nov 2008

Disc check looks for chains of clusters that do not link to anything and bad blocks on the Hard Drive and tries to fix them, SFC /SCANNOW looks for missing and corrupt files

  [email protected] 09:02 27 Nov 2008

Thanks everyone. Cleared it up nicely, except :-)
Is sfc scannow the same whether it is run from Command prompt or Run box?

  oldbeefer2 10:56 27 Nov 2008

Just been through a nightmare with laptop, and am fairly sure that scannow has to be run from the cmd screen - didn't seem to do anything when I ran it from 'run', just a flash on the screen then nothing. From cmd, saw the progress of the scan and then a table of the results.

  [email protected] 13:01 27 Nov 2008

Thanks oldbeefer2. I have experienced the "flash" you describe. I run scannow from the run box by placing my original I386 folder (from my installation disc) and giving it a path in the registry. Just a bit more convenient than using the cmd prompt.
Thanks everyone for taking an interest.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Samsung Galaxy S9 review

ManvsMachine and other artists put Apple's iMac Pro to the test using powerful rendering tools

What to expect at Apple's 27 March education event

Comment filmer l’écran d’un iPhone ?