Socket A Sempron v Athlon xp

  Madrat 15:35 02 Apr 2007


My sisters system is running on an Athlon xp 1900 FSB 266, I will shortly have a Sempron 2600 FSB 333 going spare, if I put it in her system will it make any notasable diferance or would it not be worth it? she is running 1gb of DDR333.

  woodchip 15:51 02 Apr 2007

Sempron is a poor mans Athlon, It will slow it down

  Madrat 15:56 02 Apr 2007

really, even though the clock speed and fsb are faster?

  woodchip 16:09 02 Apr 2007

Best way is to Bench test, or you could try PCPITSTOP click here

  woodchip 16:11 02 Apr 2007

Do it with the Athlon, then fix Sempron and test.Do not forget thermal paste on top of the CPU before fitting it

  Madrat 16:38 02 Apr 2007

I really didnt want to mess with the system if I could help it. "they dont like it up um Mr Mannaring" I didnt realise a sempron was slower than an older Athlon.

  Totally-braindead 16:45 02 Apr 2007

I'm not sure which would be faster, the Semprons were designed with less cache memory for one thing which slows them up. They are a budget chip same as Intels Celeron was a cut down version of the full Pentium.
Personally I think the difference would be slight whichever way it went. And as such I personally would be trying to decide if it was worth the bother.
Theres no harm in trying it, providing you are careful and it will only cost a bit of time and a bit of thermal paste.
But I think you might find the only way to tell the difference would be to run a benchmark program. I'd be fairly sure that performancewise they would be about the same.

  Madrat 16:55 02 Apr 2007

I think you could be right, A sempron 2600 is rated at 1833mhz with L1/L2 cache at 128k and 256k
the FSB is 333mhz the Athlon 1900+ (palomino)is rated at 1600mhz with the same cache as the sempron but its FSB is only 266mhz thats why I wonderd if the Sempron would be faster.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Dell XPS 13 9370 (2018) review

The art of 'British' pulp fiction

Best password managers for Mac

TV & streaming : comment regarder le Tournoi des Six Nations 2018 ?