Is Microsoft Security Essentials falling behind?

  hawthorn59 18:46 08 Dec 2010


Just read the review on this site of MSE and it wasnt as favourable as last year. It recommended using Avira AntiVir Personal.

What does anyone else think (esp. anyone who has read the review)?


  birdface 19:00 08 Dec 2010


click here

  jamesd1981 20:42 08 Dec 2010

i was using mse up until couple months ago and i found it has got very update hungry and intrusive, i started using the new avg which is a big improvement over avg 9.0, not download hungry and hardly any of the old annoying pop ups.

  john bunyan 21:25 08 Dec 2010

I have used Avira with no problems since switching to W7 a year ago.

  john bunyan 21:26 08 Dec 2010

I have used Avira with no problems since switching to W7 a year ago.

  john bunyan 21:27 08 Dec 2010

sorry for double post.

  mooly 12:13 09 Dec 2010

I still rate MSE highly. I'm surprised to see jamesd1981 refer to it as update hungry and intrusive. The daily auto update takes around 30 seconds to install... the only clue is a little flurry of HDD activity and the icon changing to the downloading symbol. On my settings a quick daily scan follows immediately, this time with a small pop up at bottom right of screen which collapes after 5 seconds or so. The scan takes 6 minutes with little impact on performance.
That is all I ever see of it.

The best points for me are that it impacts little on performance... on a 4 year old laptop (AMD Turion 64mobile) running Vista that's important. The other major plus is guaranteed compatability with Windows... and many threads relate to various issues with other programs.

As to effectiveness,
click here

and this (read it all)
click here

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Dell XPS 13 9370 (2018) review

No need to scan sketches into your computer with Moleskine's new smart pen

How to use 3D Touch on iPhone

Comment importer des contacts d’un iPhone à un autre iPhone ?