DVD File Size Wierdness....

  PaulB2005 17:56 05 Dec 2005

I have 4 x 1 hour mpeg files

1 - 59m 59s - 2,380,696 KB
2 - 59m 40s - 2,369,388 KB
3 - 59m 43s - 2,367,710 KB
4 - 59m 23s - 2,355,798 KB

I'm trying to burn these to 4.7Gb DVD-R

All the files are in the same format.

I burnt 1 & 2 together. In order to do the quality had to be dropped to Long Play but it worked.

I've tried to burn 3 & 4 together but it won't let me. At first it shows the same error as with 1 & 2 (ie that the files are too big and the quality has to be reduced) but after i agree to reduce the quality it says it still can't fit them on a DVD! It shows the total amount of disk space used by 3 & 4 as hugely different to 1 & 2 even though 3 & 4 equal less than 1 & 2!!

Any explanation?

  PaulB2005 17:57 05 Dec 2005

Sorry I'm using Nero Vision Express to burn them as movie files with a very basic menu set up. 1 & 2 left loads of free space after it was burnt but the shorter 3 & 4 videos won't fit!

Make your movie for 3 and 4 but select the option to burn to a hard drive folder. Then use RECODE to shrink to fit.

  PaulB2005 19:46 05 Dec 2005

But then why does 1 & 2 fit on when they are larger?

I have no idea why they dont fit. All I am doing is providing a possible solution.

  De Marcus™ 13:08 06 Dec 2005

Are they all the same framerate, pal or ntsc, 16:9, 4:3 etc?

  PaulB2005 13:09 06 Dec 2005

tommo2000 - Sorry. You idea was very much appreciated but i really wanted to know why it behaved like that.

De Marcus™ - Yes but i'll double check now.

  PaulB2005 13:11 06 Dec 2005

All as follows:


720 x 576

CCIR-601 D1

  PaulB2005 13:12 06 Dec 2005

and PAL

  stlucia 13:13 06 Dec 2005

Could it be something to do with the amount of compression being related to the actual content -- not just the original size -- of the files?

For instance, if you use WinZip (I know it's not the same), you'll see some files compressed 90% and some only 10%; so files starting out the same size end up different sizes when compressed.

  PaulB2005 13:22 06 Dec 2005

Now you're thinking what i'm thinking.

If i follow then it's possible that a 55 minute clip could end up being bigger than a 45 minutes lip when burnt to DVD??? Once burnt to DVD it is "uncompressed" as it where? A file with more information will decompress bigger.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

iMac Pro review

See iconic duo Smith and Foulkes' epic animation for the BBC's Winter Olympics coverage

iMac Pro review

Idées cadeaux pour geeks et tech addicts