Belkin 5-Port Network Switch (10/100Mbps) 

  Mr_Nice_Guy 19:34 29 Nov 2003

hi has anyone had any experience of this product. could i use it to share my internet and make ahome network? does a switch work the same way as a router? thanks in advance.


This product was found here click here and it looks easy enough to set up. just wanted some reviews and advice.

  bremner 19:56 29 Nov 2003

No a switch does not work the same way as a router.

If you want to share the internet so each machine has full bandwidth you need a router not a switch

  Mr_Nice_Guy 20:08 29 Nov 2003

what do you mean full bandwidth?

  Mr_Nice_Guy 20:09 29 Nov 2003

it states that it can share internet.

  bremner 20:11 29 Nov 2003

My understanding , and I stand to be corrected, is say you have three computers and all want to use the connection at the same time.

With a router all have full bandwidth. With a switch each machine will only have a third of the bandwidth.

  Mr_Nice_Guy 20:13 29 Nov 2003

how can i have full bandwidth with a router. it doesnt make sense. sutrely the more connected to the net the slower the network will be.

  Jimmyjames 20:19 29 Nov 2003

A router makes one external connection to the internet and shares it between computers connected to it, so your ISP thinks there is only one device connected.
You will have heard of a hub, which is just a type of junction box connecting computers together to form a network? This sends all the network traffic down all of the lines at the same time.
A switch is an intelligent hub that remembers where each device is and only sends the relevant traffic down each line.
Sooo.... a router is a switch with a modem built in.
Either use the switch to make the network and use internet connection sharing from one computer on the network, or use the router to make the connection (the Gateway) and each computer connects through it.
Hope that makes sense.
You don't say how many computers, what OS's and how well you understand configuring networks, which all affect the choice of solution.

  Mr_Nice_Guy 20:23 29 Nov 2003

well i am connecting 2 pcs running winxp pro on one and win me on another. Thanks guys, i have now cancelled that other modem, i was scaredd it wouldnt work well and am now ordering a much better one. thanks all for advice and help.

  Mr_Nice_Guy 20:24 29 Nov 2003

oops should reas 'switch'

  Jimmyjames 20:24 29 Nov 2003

sorry, took so long to type my reply missed bremners posting.
Sorry, bremner, but if there's only one connection with three computers, they each can only have a third of the bandwidth irrespective of the connection method if all connect at the same time. The difference is that arouter is more efficient at sharing the available bandwidth and so will run slightly faster.
On a home network you are extremely unlikely to see any difference, but on a commercial network of twenty or thirty that would be a big difference.

  Mr_Nice_Guy 20:27 29 Nov 2003

hi again, this is the router i bought click here will this do? any advice? thank you all.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Motorola Moto G6 review: Hands-on

The best smart speaker: Apple HomePod vs Google Home vs Amazon Echo

Les meilleurs jeux gratuits pour Mac (2018)