advice on buying a photo negative scanner

  pharte 21:10 30 Dec 2003

I have thousands of old photos I want to scan and put into my pc / onto disc, what are the deciding factors when buying a negative scanner and any other issues to consider?

  sdf 21:29 30 Dec 2003

i use a visioneer 9020 for that purpose and it does it very well. I have found 1600dpi to be about right as then the images can be zoomed, stretched etc if the mood took you.

  dewskit 21:31 30 Dec 2003

What format are the original negs/transparencies in?

I have had good results from 6 x 7 and 6 x 4.5 negs using an Epson Perfection 1240U Photo scanner, which comes with a lightbox to provide illumination when scanning. (I know there is a later model now though)

If 35 mm, might also work OK with the Epson, but for the best possible results there are specialist scanners from Canon and Nikon - Morgans had some at reduced prices a while back

Hope this helps

  pharte 21:38 30 Dec 2003

all my negatives are 35mm film from the photo shop, I would prefer a stand alone negative scanner rather than a general scanner but not the professional (expensive) type

  dewskit 21:54 30 Dec 2003

Just had a look on Jessops website (click here) and they have the Epson Perfection 2400 with built in transparency/negative illumination in their sale @ £128.90 think this would probably do everything you need - comes with Photoshop Elements too.

  Ixora 22:00 30 Dec 2003

Jessops do negative scanners at quite a low price compared to the more expensive Cannon & Nikon ones. They have one at £349.00 and their own brand at £369.00. at click here

  Ixora 22:16 30 Dec 2003

If you want the ultimate in quility then a dedicated negative scanner is a must. If you do not want to pay the high price for a dedicated scanner then as dewskit says the flatbed Epson Perfection 2400 is a very good buy. At the moment I am in the process of scanning approx 16,000 slides into Fotostation 4.5 in order to keep a record of what I send to librarys and publishers worldwide useing an Epson Perfection 1260. This scanner is quite adequate for my needs although the spec is less than the 2400. At £128.90 the 2400 is a good buy.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

iMac Pro review

See iconic duo Smith and Foulkes' epic animation for the BBC's Winter Olympics coverage

iMac Pro review

Idées cadeaux pour geeks et tech addicts