HD Freeview vs Freesat

  john bunyan 17:32 25 Mar 2010

Our area is not yet Freeview HD compatible, and to run coax for Freesat under floorboarsd etc is a pain. I would like to be ready for HD(free) and notice some TV's (Panasonic and Sony) offering built in Freesat or Freeview HD tuners. Is there a difference in the quality on the screen between Freesat or Freeview HD? Are ther sets with both tuners? I am fed up with buying a so called HD TV only to find a set top box is needed to receive free broadcasts in HD ! (Dont go on about 3D!!)

  dms_05 07:55 26 Mar 2010

If you follow the Freeview/Freesat route it looks as if you will be limited to the BBC part time HD service and the soon to be launched ITV1 HD . C4HD and FIVE HD are only available if you have a Sky Viewing Card.

It seems as if the BBC and ITV are trying to equalise their HD services on Freeviw and Freesat by degrading the bit rate on satellite so it's no better picture quality than HD will be on terrestrial.

You really need to see some full quality HD from Sky to make a judgement on the various picture quality issues of broadcast HD. If you can also look at some Blu-ray HD on the same receiver.

Good SD is quite acceptable on a medium sized HD TV (say 37" or smaller) but HD does begin to show it's improvement on bigger TV's (say 42" or bigger). However it's all down to personal evaluation of the actual picture quality. Remember some SD is much better than other SD and expect differences.

ITV/BBC broadcast to a horizontal resolution of 1440 whereas Sky broadcast it's own HD channels to a horizontal resolution of 1920 so you do get a better PQ on Sky although BBC/ITV HD can be quite acceptable.

I have Sky HD and do view HD programming when available. However the difference between SD and HD often isn't massive especially when the broadcasters simply upscale SD content to HD resolution.

Is HD worth the £'s you need to spend? Only you can tell but if you are interested in Sport then HD is almost mandatory.

  john bunyan 08:34 26 Mar 2010

Thanks for a very useful post. I am not a keen sports watcher, and do not want to pay for Sky, so I will watch and wait to see how the "free" HD market develops. If buying a new TV only for free hd, it seems there is little to choose between sat and freeview.

  dms_05 08:57 26 Mar 2010

Freeview will always be limited to a small number of HD channels due to space. Freesat MAY have more HD channels available in the long run as it has theoretically more space available (but even that is complicated by satellite footprint for FTA transmissions).

  john810 09:51 01 Apr 2010
  john bunyan 11:30 01 Apr 2010

This looks like spam?

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Dell XPS 13 9370 (2018) review

No need to scan sketches into your computer with Moleskine's new smart pen

WWDC history: Apple's product launches since 2005

Comment importer des contacts d’un iPhone à un autre iPhone ?