which pc is better

  nicelad100 15:39 13 Aug 2006

one has Intel Pentium D 805 Dual Core

click here

and the other has AMD ATHLON 64X2 4200+

click here

  nicelad100 15:40 13 Aug 2006

also which is better intel or amd for the processor

  DieSse 16:45 13 Aug 2006

Better what?

Price? - Performance? (and performance for which tasks?) - Quietness? - Storage capacity? - Looks? - Operating System?

  Jimmy14 16:56 13 Aug 2006

Definitely the 2nd computer for the processor wise. For your second post, Intel currently stand as best for processors due to their release of Core 2 duo, but out of a pentium D 805 and athlon 64 X2 4200 the athlon would be better. I would fork the extra £26 for the athlon but one thing that concerns me is the graphics. I wouldn't have a powerful processor and a good amount of ram with a 128mb NVIDIA 6150 graphics.

  Totally-braindead 17:09 13 Aug 2006

To me the two important things to have when buying a new PC are balance and upgradability.

Regarding balance, there is no point having a PC with a mega graphics card for example if the processor drags it down. Look for a balanced set of components. Regarding upgradability, make sure whether it has onboard graphics or not, that it has a PCI Express slot so you can install a new graphics card. Also make sure that there is a slot free for adding more memory if you want. Other things to look for are that the PC has SATA for the hard drives or better still SATA II which is faster.

Regarding the two PCs I personally like the second one, the AMD based one better but would consider another company and a different PC. A bigger hard drive would be nice as would a proper graphics card. Must admit its cracking value though at that price.

  SG Atlantis® 17:16 13 Aug 2006

The second one wins hands down.

  phoenix198 00:01 14 Aug 2006

Agree with SG Atlantis® that on the face of it the second pc (Athlon 4200 X2) appears to win hand down.

But (there's always one of those!):

- 250W PSU is a bit weak should you later want to install a more powerful graphics card - anthing above a NVidia 7600GT (which is in itself a pretty decent card) is likely to need additional power. Personally I would upgrade to a 550W PSU - a £25 option on the Mesh website

- Only one optical drive. Not necessarily a problem to most users.

- Note the lack of speakers. Mesh site has options available from £10 (ugh!) upwards. Personally I'd go for the iTrigue 2.1 speakers at £45

But as DieSse said, it all depends on what you want to use the PC for. If you aren't into games, then its a very decent PC as is (with speakers of course)

  nicelad100 07:54 14 Aug 2006

thanks for all your information , i will not be useing it to palys games as i got a xbox and ps2 for that and i will be getting ps3, i will be adding these to the pc spec

250GB Serial ATA Hard Drive with 16MB Buffer[upg £ 20.00

512MB DDR2 nVIDIA GeForce 7300GS - TV out- DVI - PCI X (256Mb SMA)[upg £ 40.00]

is the graphics card better than the one you get with pc

  phoenix198 23:14 14 Aug 2006

Yes the 7300 GS is a significantly better performer than the 6150.

You might find the article here click here interesting. It doesn't review the exact model you intend to get but it will give you an idea of how the 7300GS performs.

Given the number of postings regarding Mesh customer service it would be interesting to have your opinion if you do follow through on purchasing this PC.

  nicelad100 07:51 15 Aug 2006

hi there i have decided to get this pc instead

click here

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Dell XPS 13 9370 (2018) review

Creative studio Omnibus' brand identity for We Said Enough fights back against sexual misconduct

WWDC history: Apple's product launches since 2005

Espace de stockage : comment libérer de la mémoire sur votre iPhone ?