DEll sharp practice

  tim666 16:16 18 May 2012

I bought a new Dell Computer 2 weeks ago and it has a faulty hard drive. The on line technical help desk at Dell advised to get the hard disc replaced but when I checked with customer service if Dell are prepared to guarantee the replacement part will be new they refused saying their policy is to replace from stock which may be new or "refurbished". Surely my consumer rights mean I can insist that I get a new hard disc replacement?

  birdface 16:25 18 May 2012

If it was me I would be wanting a new one, or even a new computer.

Must be someone higher up the ladder that you can contact.

Not sure what your legal rights are on this but I am sure someone will be able to give you the proper details.

  tim666 17:21 18 May 2012

Yes the issue is, do my consumer rights enable me to insist I get a new replacement for a faulty hard drive in a 2 week old PC that was not fit for purpose or does Dell's policy small print over-ride this right?

  carver 18:42 18 May 2012

You would have thought that you should get a new hard drive but some where in the small print you may find that they are allowed to fit a refurb unit.

But if you complain hard enough they should fit a new drive.

Sky have a similar get out clause in their small print in relation to their HD Boxes.

  morddwyd 20:47 18 May 2012

Dell have to prove the fault was not there when they supplied it, and they would find that difficult.

You are entitled to a new (not refurbished) computer, not just a hard drive (if you agree to just the hard drive you place yourself outside consumer protection legislation).

  spuds 13:09 19 May 2012

Dell are not using 'sharp practice', because that is the standard procedures most manufacturer's use for supplying a replacement part under warranty. The refurbished part, should have all the same quality control checks as a new unit.

You should also consider, that if the hard drive is replaced, then all previous activity on that hard drive would be lost. Dell or any other manufacturer would not retrieve or transfer any data for you.

Due to the computer only being two weeks old, you could probably insist that you have no confidence in the product, then go from there?.

  frybluff 21:26 20 May 2012

I had a somewhat similar issue. To be fair, I couldn't fault Dell's tech support, at trying to resolve the problem, they just weren't getting anywhere, and didn't have the authority to "make a decision".

It took a couple of "suitably worded" recorded letters, to "Customer Services Director", at their Dublin office (don't bother with UK address), to get an "executive", on the case. Strangely, he was able to offer a "full refund", but not a replacement. (I still can't work that one out).

Anyway, it was eventually arranged that they would send an engineer, to my home, and fit the necessary new part. Problem solved, but quite a bit of effort, getting there.

  finerty 00:21 22 May 2012

so tim smith do as frybuff suggests and maybe use special delivery

  onthelimit1 09:16 22 May 2012

'all the same quality control checks as a new unit. '

Which failed in a fortnight!. I assume you bought on line? In which case, distance selling regs apply.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Samsung Galaxy A8 review: Hands-on

Majority of illustrators don’t earn enough to live from, new survey shows

iPhone X problems

Word gratuit : comment télécharger le logiciel de Microsoft ?