Comet vs Amazon for an Xbox360

  cactusjack 11:09 27 Oct 2011

Hello all,

Has anyone bought a Xbox360 from, developed faults and had to return it? Was Amazon easy to deal with for returns/repair?

Likewise, has anyone had experiences with Comet?

I was thinking Comet would be easy, since if there was a fault, you could walk into the store and return - however, I have read lots of horror stories online.

I have never bought a big electrical item from amazon before - but can't find many horror stories regarding returns.

In either case, I would take out the 3 year £30 extended warranty/insurance just to be safe.

Any advice is recommended.

Thank you.

  cactusjack 11:14 27 Oct 2011

Woops - that should have said 'any advice would be gratefully received'.

  birdface 13:59 27 Oct 2011

Absolutely no help whatever to you but thought that I would answer both.

I never had to send anything back to Amazon or E-buyer both of them good to use especially with the free delivery.

Comet.My daughter got a Laptop out of Comet and took it back as it would not start up.They put a new battery in it and it started first time but also sent it away for a service so no complaints from Comet Either.

3 year warranty is probably not advertised properly as the first year you automatically get it covered free.So not sure why companies always say 3 year warranty.

Sometimes the 3 year warranty you get does not cover you for accidental damage so you have to read the small print before buying. It Usually covers you for accidental damage for the first year only.After that it will be parts only.

Though that I would give you something to read till someone can give you the details that you are looking for.

I have heard numerous good reports about Amazons returns policy but like I said I have not had to return anything before,

  cactusjack 14:32 27 Oct 2011

Thanks Buteman - I have gone with Amazon in the end :)

  BT 17:37 27 Oct 2011

I once bought a Microwave from Comet. What a disaster. It went rusty inside and they insisted on a repair rather than a replacement - 3 TIMES!! Eventually they said to call out the repair man rather than take it into the shop, who said to keep calling him out at £49 per call out, which I did till the guarantee ran out. It must have cost them several hundred pounds in all rather than £100 for a new replacement.

Bought my next one in Argos,a DeLongi, and its now 6 years old and I've never had a problem with it, and it was cheaper.

I've also bought many large electrical items from Amazon, with no problems.

  daveeb 11:59 06 Nov 2011

I've just bought one for the kids. Eventually plumped for Argos as they had a good offer. Other vendors i considered were Amazon and Game. You could also try one of the big supermarkets as they tend to be fairly helpful when problems arise. My personal experiences with Comet/Currys/PCW mean that i would only buy from them as a last resort.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Samsung Galaxy S9 review

Wacom Cintiq Pro 24 and 32 review – hands-on

When is the next Apple event?

Qu’est-ce qu’Amazon Prime ?