peer to peer lending, anyone?

  rickf 16:54 07 May 2013

Anyone here lending money using these sites now that Zoopa and RateSetter have both provided insurance against loss? What do you think and if you have used them what is your experience as a lender. 5% returns are not to be sniffed at in the present economic climate.

  wiz-king 17:10 07 May 2013

Kid's have been running that system for years but the return rate is iffy.

  bumpkin 18:22 07 May 2013

In principle it seems a sensible system and 5% is a good return. Who runs it, who regulates it and how safe is your money would be my concerns. The higher the return the greater the risk generally. I am tempted myself but also need to learn more before committing.

  oresome 19:41 07 May 2013

Provident Financial Group is a Bradford based commercial doorstep lender in the FTSE 250 and has a projected yield of 4.7% plus the potential for capital gain (or loss).

  LastChip 15:30 08 May 2013

I have invested in Zopa in the past, but in real terms, the amount of effort required by me to get a favourable return outweighed any benefits.

I did suffer losses (not overall), but that really hammers your overall return and frankly, I can make more in the stock market than I can messing with peer to peer.

Zopa, like RateSetter has recently offered a guaranteed return, but as I'd already decided not to pursue this type of investment, I didn't study it any further.

They claim their underwriting is second to none, but I would dispute that, when they lent out some of my cash to projects that were obviously going nowhere. Ultimately, they need to turnover cash to make money and in some cases, in my view, their underwriting was dubious to say the least.

They also made changes to the system after the contract between me and the borrower were both locked in. Mostly, they were not in the lenders favour and for example, changes were made to bad debt recovery. Some were designed to lower API rates to make Zopa look more attractive. They also made changes to lenders fees which negated a promise made right at the start that lenders wouldn't pay fees. Who paid the price overall? Lenders!

Be aware, none of these peer to peer landing sites are covered by the Financial Compensation Scheme, so ultimately, you could loose everything you invest on these sites.

Buyer beware!

  bumpkin 16:04 08 May 2013

Lastchip, that has put me off, loads of info and offers on the web of course but none or questionable guarantees, better to play safe in my opinion, especially after your experiences, thanks.

  bumpkin 16:12 08 May 2013

This sounds a bit like the old Names at LLoyds controversy where it was alleged that new members were given the higher risks and the "old School" kept the best for themselves.

  rickf 17:22 08 May 2013

That's really helpful to know. I was thinking of handing over a small sum to try it out. Would like to hear if there are any others here with experience.

  oresome 19:11 08 May 2013

What is your objective?

Is it altruism or to earn a return on your money?

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

OnePlus 5T review: Hands-on

Illustrator Andrés Lozano on his improv line work, brazen use of colours & hand sketching

iPhone X review

Comment envoyer gratuitement des gros fichiers ?