Dads Army

  daz60 21:08 27 Sep 2011

Sad to see the demise of David Croft who alongside his writing partner Jimmy Perry gave us the definitive take on "British" humour.Wholesome and ribald not vulgar and expletive riddled.

  daz60 21:09 27 Sep 2011
  Quickbeam 07:48 28 Sep 2011

I'll be the first to say,'they don't write comedy like that any more'!

The best one for me is the one when Godfrey is ostracised by the platoon when they find out he was a Great War conshie, then when he's on his death bed they find out he won a Military Medal as a stretcher bearer in no-man's land, very emotive with little slapstick that one.

  dagbladet 08:51 28 Sep 2011

I have recently started watching the DVD's from the start and feel that whilst enjoyable it was to a fair degree 'of it's time'. I think perhaps the reason "they don't write comedy like that any mor"'is that there is less appetite for it. However, your reference to Godfrey's death bed scene (I haven't got to that one yet), reminds me of the incredibly poignant conclusion of Blackadder goes Forth written by Richard Curtis and Ben Elton. They don't write comedy like that anymore ;-)

  BT 09:04 28 Sep 2011

incredibly poignant

I think the biggest Sitcom tear jerker for me was when Compo (Bill Owen) died in Last of the Summer Wine and they had a whole group of people in white overalls spell out 'Goodbye Compo' across the hillside.

  Aitchbee 11:28 28 Sep 2011

The late David Croft said this: The last recording was a very emotional experience for us all. The production gallery was unusually quiet during the recording and a truckload of lumps were in a lot of throats...we had all enjoyed a glorious success and to stop, albeit at the top, was a wrench. 'Never Too Old' ended with the platoon drinking a toast to the Home Guard as Mainwaring delivered his final patriotic speech: "Anybody tries to take our homes or or freedom away from us, they'll find out what we can do. We'll fight. And we're not alone, there are thousands of us all over England...Scotland...Great Britain, in fact, Men who'll stand together when their country needs them." There wasn't a dry eye in the studio."

  onthelimit1 11:35 28 Sep 2011

It's fascinating how things stick in the mind - ask anyone 'and what's your name?' will always get the response 'don't tell him Pike'. Wonderful stuff.

  Aitchbee 12:15 28 Sep 2011

Arthur Lowe's Biography is a must for Dad's Army fans.All of the main characters in Dad's Army get a mention, 'in dispatches'.

  Quickbeam 12:42 28 Sep 2011

Quiz Question: Who were the two regularly mentioned characters that were never seen?


  onthelimit1 13:52 28 Sep 2011

Mrs Mainwaring and........

  Terry Brown 14:28 28 Sep 2011

I agree with a lot of these comments because todays 'Scriptwriters' seem to think unless it must have a lot of Sex & Violence in every series / film.

The art of clean comedy seems to be lost.

This is properbly why a lot of the old favorites like Dads Army, Fools & Horses etc are still around.


This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

iPhone X review

Political cartoons in 2017: Chris Riddell, Rebecca Hendin and Dave Brown on what it’s like to…

The best iPhone for 2017

Tennis : comment regarder la finale de la Coupe Davis 2017 ?