WD External 500GB USB HD

  David4637 16:24 26 Dec 2008

I am thinking of buying the above to backup XP SP2 lappy, and a W98SE desktop. It will supplied with FAT32. Will there be a prob on it being recognised (550GB) on either PC? Thanks David

  Technotiger 16:27 26 Dec 2008

You can easily do a Quick Format to make it NTFS, which is what I strongly advise you to do.

  David4637 17:40 26 Dec 2008

1. I thought that W998SE would NOT recognise NTFS, thats why they supply the drive with FAT32, to cover XP & W98SE OS systems?

2. Will both XP & W98SE recognise this large size of drive or will it require partitioning?
Thanks David

  Technotiger 17:51 26 Dec 2008

As you are only putting back-ups on it, and not actually wanting to run the different OS's, I don't think it will do any harm.

  David4637 18:22 26 Dec 2008

Thanks for your replies - I will use it with Acronis on each of the OS's, for restoring disc images if the OS crashes,hence my queries on the 2 OS I will be using it with? Thanks David

  Technotiger 08:52 27 Dec 2008

If it was me, I would do as I suggested simply because, if there was any problem due to Formatting one way or the other, I would rather the problem was with Win98 and not XP.

But as I said earlier, I don't think there will be any problem as you are only saving the back-ups, not running the OS's on the external hard drive.

  David4637 13:46 27 Dec 2008

Thanks for your confident reply. I decided to buy it, will let you know outcome. Still unsure whether OS W98SE will recognise a 500GB drive, without it being partitioned first - well see? Thanks again David

  David4637 14:06 30 Dec 2008


Drive arrived works brilliantly, quiet.

1. OS XP - Did Acronis on the C:, took 5 mins to this drive 6 GB.

2. XP Normal backup of data 20GB photos etc 20 mins.

3. OS W98SE NOT yet tried will update you.

4. SO FAR THE BEST THING SINCE SLICED BREAD cost £50 - piece of mind YES. Thanks David

  Technotiger 15:50 30 Dec 2008

Grreat, thanks for your feedback - good luck with W98SE backup.

  David4637 12:47 01 Jan 2009

I can not get the new drive to work on my W98SE PC. It has a yellow ? against External Drive WD 500 GB but appears to require a driver to be installed. Any ideas please? Thanks David

  ICF 12:54 01 Jan 2009

Try this from WD site click here

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Fujitsu Lifebook P727 laptop review

Converse's new logo: the trainer brand looks to its heritage for a fresh identity

Mac power user tips and hidden tricks

Comment lancer Windows 10 en mode sans échec ?