I think it should be made clear its a two action procedure. You can't post and tick at the same time. Either post a reply and go back and tick, or tick then add a reply, not both together because one or t'other go missing.
This has been brought up many times, and while I wholeheartedly agree with the sentiments. Many people it seems just can't be bothered. Perhaps (Though I doubt) they will listen to what is said here. The real point is that if someone solves a specific problem it is there for all to see & learn, and is also available under the Forum Search Facility.