HDD fail... Sound track included!

  Gaz 25 19:27 19 Feb 2004

Is this HDD clapperd...

click here

I think so, but more opinions are better.

Its a Maxtor 80Gb 8Mb Cache HDD.


  spikeychris 19:33 19 Feb 2004

"Its a Maxtor 80Gb 8Mb Cache HDD."....no its not, its a doorstop. Sounds a bit rough Gaz..

  Tony 19:35 19 Feb 2004

Sounds like either one of the heads has dropped off or maybe the pin that the arm moves on has gone.
Any way one dead hdd.
I have hear worse one it fact sounded like someone banging a hammer on the inside of the hdd, took it appart and found that a screw that holds the platters to the motor had the head broken off and the scratch markes on the platters had to be seen to be belived.

  Gaz 25 19:41 19 Feb 2004

Yep, note the clicking before. Then the loud click.

Well the place I bought the drive from said that the clicking is normal. Ummm... I dont think so.

Thanks for your backup!!!


PS. Anymore views are welcome.

  GANDALF <|:-)> 19:43 19 Feb 2004

Knackered...bin...buy new.


  Gaz 25 19:50 19 Feb 2004

Its in its 12 months warranty. Infact I only had it a month after my IBM failed.


  Gaz 25 19:51 19 Feb 2004

You get straight to the point dont you Gandalf?

  SGT [email protected] 19:52 19 Feb 2004

more like take back if still under warranty , and change or get money back if they wont , launch it shop windowards

  Gaz 25 19:54 19 Feb 2004


This is what I am up against, I taken it back yesterday and they wanted to hear it make that click, but it is intermittent and it behaves for them. Ghrrrr.

What can I do?

  Gongoozler 19:56 19 Feb 2004

I hav found Maxtor very good on warranty replacements. They send you a new one, and you return the faulty unit in the same box. The only down side is that you pay the postage for the returned unit.

  Gaz 25 20:00 19 Feb 2004

Ummm, its an OEM drive so no box only antistatic bag. ;-)

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Xiaomi Mi Mix 2 review

What went wrong at the Designs of the Year 2017

iPhone X news: Release date, price, new features & specs

Comment regarder des séries et talk-shows américains en France ?