DVDRW + or -?

  katswhiskers 10:17 11 Nov 2004

Which is best a DVDRW that is + or -?

  no-name 10:30 11 Nov 2004

katswhiskers if your referring to PC drives then I think you'll find most are dual purpose anyway now, so there's not really a question to answer.

If you're referring to the discs, then whatever's cheapest because again most DVD players can replay both formats.

  geezore 10:32 11 Nov 2004

I am having the same trouble deciding myself mate!
I think it all depends on what you plan on doing with it. If video is your thing, or still photos etc that you may want to playback on a normal DVD player (as well as the computer DVD drive) then you need to make sure your set-top DVD player accepts the format that your DVD burner is able to create. I think you will find that any new burners are likely to be dual mode so can create + and - disks, (and more and more are dual layer, ie 8-9 GB on one disc, ideal for those long video recordings you may use them for)
My Pioneer DVD player only really seems to be guaranteed to play DVD-R, so that is what I am sticking to.
If you are only going to play the burned DVD in your computer, then it does not really matter I think. But I am no expert.

There does seem to be a differnce in the rate at which DVDs can be burned in the + and - formats. Some are faster at + and other at -. But I do not think that speed of burning is a top priority, much more important to have a trouble free burn, albeit slightly slower. (I can live with 4 X speed, can you?)
So long you have a good processor with lots of RAM, as well as at least 2MB data buffer on your DVD burner, then you should be fine.
I am sure some proper experts will add to this!


  katswhiskers 19:15 11 Nov 2004

It's just that I'm thinking of buying a Systemax Tourbook which has a DVDRW+. I have no need for the DVD bit at the moment, but I probably will in the future.

I see, so when I buy a DVD player to go with the TV, if I get a multi one I can play the + ones on that. I get it.

I wonder which is most popular tho + or -?

  SEASHANTY 20:25 11 Nov 2004

Popularity - according to this website
click here

  geezore 09:06 12 Nov 2004

"Multi" with DVD set-top players usually just means multiregion (ie DVDs from anywhere in the world) it does not mean it plays DVD+R and DVD-R

Generally Sony and Phillips play +R and Pioneer and others play -R. However if you check on the web you may find some DVD players that play back both formats.

I think that -R is most popular, but I can't seems to find -R disks that support the new dual layer burning (IE 9GB on one disk)


This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

OnePlus 5T review: Hands-on

Illustrator Andrés Lozano on his improv line work, brazen use of colours & hand sketching

iPhone X review

Comment envoyer gratuitement des gros fichiers ?