98SE vs XP

  faichfolds 00:29 05 Jul 2003

What's the feeling regaurding overall stability, useability, "fun", tweaking, value for money etc. for these systems?

  VoG II 00:34 05 Jul 2003

XP is easier to use, more stable, not sure that any system is "fun", and very tweakable e.g/. click here

  faichfolds 00:39 05 Jul 2003

Who was it that posted about an OS based on a well tweaked 98 that was phenominally quick and used very little memory?

In my experience XP lets you do very little.

(I Should mention I work for a Worldwide renowned software house involved with Operating Systems)

  VoG II 00:40 05 Jul 2003

Oh, and has System Restore. This does work most of the time.

  faichfolds 00:42 05 Jul 2003

Only most of the time, and with everything that you want?

  Ironman556 00:47 05 Jul 2003

I found from "playing" with my dad's machine that XP is quite boring if you want to tweak. There are tweaking toold avaliable though. It is very very stable (unless you force the wrong drivers on.. oopse).

If you're buying a new PC you may be better to go with XP, more of the hardware coming out is aimed to work with XP rather than older OS versions. All should still work with 98, but some reject it, but work fine with XP.

  soy 00:47 05 Jul 2003

Xp is very stable. I experimented with 98SE on a dual boot with XP home last year and in the few weeks I used it, 98SE crashed dozens of times to the point of it not even loading up anymore. XP hasn't had a major crash since I bought it.

BTW, if you work for a renowned software house with operating systems, wouldn't you have tried XP already?

  VoG II 00:48 05 Jul 2003

software house involved with Operating Systems)

So why ask the question?

I cannot claim such high credentials - I merely have to use the operating systems that I buy or are provided for me at work.

At work I have W98 which crashes from time to time. Our IT people, in their wisdom, have disabled everything that might have led me to a solution. Their solution is: reformat and re-install. Time and time again.

At home I have XP. It is incredibly stable - I just do not have BSODs or crashes anymore.

Given the above, which would you choose?

  faichfolds 00:51 05 Jul 2003

Yes I have. Rubbish. MArketing push explains all!

  powerless 00:52 05 Jul 2003

Well Windows XP of course.

  Djohn 00:53 05 Jul 2003

XP is extremely stable and user friendly, also fast and pleasant to use. There is quite a bit you can do to XP, but better to let it run as is.

Win. 98se is also excellent to use and can be fine tuned as much as you want to. I ran 98se as my operating system for two years, never had any problems at all, Have been using XP Pro for 4 months or so and would not like to change back. j.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

WPA2 hack: How secure is your Wi-Fi?

Add Depth Of Field to a photo using Tilt Shift Blur in Photoshop

iPhone tips & tricks

Les meilleures tablettes 2017