Which external hard drive should I buy?

  notlongnow 11:58 23 Oct 2005

I'm looking for an external hard drive, at least 160GB, probably more, to store music, pictures, documents and backups. Some portability would be nice, but only needed four or five times a year.
Seagate external 200GB(or even 400) or freecom 250GB seem likely. Any opinions...

  Starfox 13:02 23 Oct 2005

Have a look at this click here

  freaky 13:07 23 Oct 2005

Do a search for a 160GB External HD USB(2). Ideally you need one with it's own On/Off switch, especiall as you will only need to use it occasionally.

I use a Maxtor One Touch, this is a well made product in a sturdy case - ON/Off switch at rear, power supply and function indicator light.

Maxtor also give excellent after-sales service, with email assistance.

Also recommend using Acronis True Image for creating backups and cloning your existing HD to the external HD.

To get the best performance with an external drive, you need to have USB(2)connections on your MOB. If you only have USB(1), then you will need to purchase a USB(2) PCI Card. These are quite cheap, and plug into a spare PCI socket on your MOB.

  notlongnow 14:16 23 Oct 2005

freaky, thanks for the response. I suppose if I run acronis true image then the one touch button seems a bit redundant?

  freaky 16:59 23 Oct 2005

Quite correct, you would not need it. Acronis used in conjunction with a Maxtor external, or any other external HD, would do all that you require.

  JYPX 20:55 23 Oct 2005

One advantage of buying the Freecom FHD-3 is that it comes with Acronis True Image.

  wee eddie 22:18 23 Oct 2005

My "old" Maxtor does not have an on/off switch.

You have to handle that through the PC before you disconnect it.

Don't know about the new ones.

  EARLR 12:49 24 Oct 2005

I have a 250 GB hd from lidi paid 140 € works fine.

As I recall, I think Maxtor and Lacie had the best warranties (european) at 2 years. Western Digital, Seagate and Freecom, Samsung and IBM (though unconfirmed) only offered 1 year. This is in contrast to the 3 - 5 year warranties provided for internal hard disk drives (by same manufacturers).

If you want to back up pictures taken with digital cameras, then WD had external drives with memory card readers built in. Seems nice and convenient.

Other external hard disk drives are more versatile still, and can play back a host of Divx type video files, MP3s and photos to your home entertainment system (telly). They're not as significantly more expensive as standard 'back up only' drives as you might think. Pixmania had some in. The WD memory card reader models can be purchased from the likes of Overclockers.co.uk.

  Joe R 17:01 24 Oct 2005


you could also buy an external caddy (ide or sata) with an usb2 connector, which would allow you to buy a cheaper, internal drive.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

iPhone X review

Political cartoons in 2017: Chris Riddell, Rebecca Hendin and Dave Brown on what it’s like to…

The best iPhone for 2017

Tennis : comment regarder la finale de la Coupe Davis 2017 ?