what speakers for music?

  Giggsy252 08:29 03 Oct 2007


I am in a dilemma. dont know what speakers to get for my PC. Mainly for music and little bit of films.

Logitech Z2300 £90

Or these BOSE COmpaninion 3 for £200

HEard the Bose in person, sound so crisp!! But heard very good reviews regarding Z2300 and its half the price.

What one do you people recommend?

  interzone55 12:38 03 Oct 2007

Bose any day if you can afford them.

  Giggsy252 16:02 03 Oct 2007

any others?

I was having exactly the same dilemma as you not so long ago. There seems to be very few articles on the internet actually comparing the two.

Most research suggests that BOSE speakers are over-priced for what they are and that you're just paying for the brand.

I eventually decided on the Logitech Speakers which are excellent, however, I cannot help feeling that the BOSE speakers sounded better when I heard them (which was many years ago though). I would like to listen to them again since I purchased the Logitech speakers but all the shops that sell them locally don't actually demonstrate them any more.

Another set I was considering which are supposed to be in the same league (in fact, most people recommend these specifically over the BOSE Companion 3) is the Acoustic Energy Aego M. I've heard these and these too are very good. The only reason I didn't buy them was because you had little control over the bass (3 settings) and I was living in University Halls of Residence at the time.

Good luck with whichever set you choose.

If you want more information of the AE Aego M then here are some reviews:

click here, click here, click here.

The RRP is £99 but this is the cheapest I could find them click here (£79)

  Stuartli 16:43 03 Oct 2007

Hi-fi specialist speakers manufacturer Altec Lansing also makes a range of excellent computer speakers:

click here

The prices may surprise you.

  wee eddie 17:32 03 Oct 2007

If you purchase a decent set speakers, their ability to reproduce the sound exceeds most of the storage methods (MP3 etc) to store it. CDs and DVD are of course an exception to this and will reproduce superbly.

Most PC systems have a collection of small Speakers and a Woofer. If you are an audiophile then you will be aware that a selection of squeaks accompanied by dull thumps is acceptable in a movie but not if you really enjoy a musicians performance. It's not really as bad as that because the whole audio range is covered but the level of fidelity is usually sorely lacking

  Curio 19:26 03 Oct 2007

click here
My son just got his. Haven't listened to them yet, but reviewers are raving about them!

  Giggsy252 20:48 03 Oct 2007

thanks everyone for your advice.

DAve i think comet are demonstrating the BOSE, yes they are very good quality!! but as you said it is worth paying double for the BOSE??


  rickf 14:18 04 Oct 2007

I use Creative 5.1 and have always been very pleased. 3 yrs on and its just as good. Great reproduction too.

  Giggsy252 10:53 07 Oct 2007

I have opted for the Logitech Z2300, Seems to give much more value for money than BOSE. should be arriving by mid week!! cant waiT!!

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Fujitsu Lifebook P727 laptop review

Converse's new logo: the trainer brand looks to its heritage for a fresh identity

Mac power user tips and hidden tricks

Comment lancer Windows 10 en mode sans échec ?