Pocket PC V PalmOne??? Recommend?

  Johnnie_M 23:00 20 Jan 2005

Hi, I'm thinking of buying a new handheld computer and I'm looking at two machines, the Palm Tungsten T5/T3 or the Dell Axim X50. I don't require Wi-Fi though do need the Bluetooth capability of both. I'm just looking at cost and whether the palm would do just as good a job as the Axim and vice versa. Just looking for advice really on whats best to buy??

  Kate B 23:31 20 Jan 2005

Ooh, this is like the debate between Mac and PC and at the end of the day it comes down to which operating system you prefer.

For the Palm OS: small, elegant OS which generally means it doesn't eat as much battery power and - generally but not always now - the pdas are physically smaller. Also good for those who dislike the Microsoft hegemony in computing.

For the Pocket PC OS: easy-peasy interface with the PC, tends to ship with Pocket versions of Word and Excel which means you can edit documents and spreadsheets on the move.

I can think of more cons for the Pocket PC than the Palm, too: against the Pocket PC is that the OS functions like a cutdown version of Windows, with all that implies for cumbersome file systems - and boy, is it cumbersome in the Pocket iteration. Lots of drilling down through folder structures. More power-hungry, too: your battery won't last as long. I've had some issues with ActiveSync (which syncs the data between your PC and the handheld) crashing my main computer.

But ... lots of software available for both.

Do consider going for a wifi option - you think you don't need it now but you might be glad of it sometime.

If you need it for work stuff you might just find the Dell Axim running Pocket PC has the edge. I've used both OSs on various PDAs and my heart belongs to the Palm OS. Having said that, I've got an iPaq at the moment running Pocket PC and I do love the extra processing power you get.

I suggest you go to a retailer and play with both PDAs, or if they don't have the models you want, at least play with machines running the two different OSs and see which you prefer.

  Johnnie_M 23:36 20 Jan 2005

Ironically, I have both sitting beside me, as I work for a retailer that sells these items, I am the owner of the Palm Tungsten T and have an Ipaq 1715 to play with. I am though struggling, don't get me wrong I love my Palm and havce had it for around 2 years, but I like the feel and functionality of the Pocket PC. I just wonder if others opinions would tip me one way or the other. So far I am impressed by thew functionality of the Tungsten T5 and it works lovely with my Mac (thanks for your previous recommendation on the iBook which I bought)

  Kate B 00:49 21 Jan 2005

Johnnie_M, delighted that you're so pleased with the iBook!

I can't advise on the Palm/PPC, though ... I'd be very torn in your shoes. If you like the PPC machine, go with it - I'm not displeased with my switch from the Palm-based Clies to the iPaq, my odd niggles notwithstanding.

You can even get the PPC working with the iPaq if you buy a third-party app: Pocket Mac. That syncs with Office for Mac reasonably well, though it's not perfect.

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

OnePlus 5T review

How to draw a mandala

iPhone X review

Les meilleures enceintes Bluetooth à moins de 150 euros