CORE 2 DUO E4500 OR AMD ATHLON 64 X2 4400?

  Razza14 08:47 01 Mar 2008

Which procssor would be the best for gaming?


  Colin 10:27 01 Mar 2008

Hi, Razza 14.

The reviews here might help. click here

One chap says he upgraded from an X2 4600 to a E4500 with great results.

  GaT7 20:39 01 Mar 2008

An E4500 C2D will overclock very well too, if you're into that kind of thing.

First get an after-market cooler like the Arctic Cooling Freezer 7 Pro (click here / click here / click here), then a good guide & forum to help you out click here. G

  Razza14 21:18 01 Mar 2008

Thanks for the replies guys! Would the e4500 with 4gb ram and a 8400 gs run cod 4 ok?

  GaT7 22:17 01 Mar 2008

A 8400GS may run it but it'll be very poor. When running games of this nature, the graphics card (GPU) is the most important component - next come CPU & RAM. In addition, the speed of the GPU's RAM rather than the amount (unless you have a very large monitor) is what to look out for.

I think you'll need something like a 7600GS or better for optimum performance. A few to choose from....

Least to go for - Innovision GeForce 7600GS 512MB DDR2 PCIE click here (read one of the long reviews lower down click here) = £38.45 excl del (free del if order over £49.99)

Recommended - for only £5-6 more, the significantly better Nvidia GeForce 7600GT 256MB DDR3 PCIE click here = £43.99 excl del (free del if order over £49.99)

If you can stump up a bit more, this Nvidia 7800GTX 256MB DDR3 PCI-E click here for just under £60 delivered is very good for the money. It's on par with a ATi X1950 Pro that goes for a bit more. But if it's only for COD4, stick with one of the 2 above.

Are you going to be playing any other games? If yes, which ones? G

P.S. You can compare performance between various GPUs at click here

  Razza14 10:28 02 Mar 2008

I will also probaly be playing battlefield 2 and call of duty 2 plus maybe other games when they come out.

  Razza14 10:32 02 Mar 2008

I looked on ebay and found a 7600 gs 512mb for £35 would this be adequate for my games.

  Totally-braindead 15:26 02 Mar 2008

Not really. I have a 7600GS and its borderline for COD4 as I've tried the demo. I had to turn a lot of the setting down or off to get it to run ok. I must say that even then it still looked good.
Assumming its PCI Express you are talking about and not AGP I would be looking for at least a 7600GT and I would check it came with DDR3 memory as some have DDR2 memory and are not quite as fast. Or a 8600GT you can get that a reasonable price.
I should point out maybe that with high graphics hungry games you will still have to lower some settings, to play some games at full settings at a high resolution you are talking about a lot of money.
My 7600GS is ok but as I said its borderline. Personally I would be looking for something like a 8600GT with 512mb RAM. That one Crossbow7 linked to the 7800GTX looks interesting especially for the price.

  Razza14 15:41 02 Mar 2008

So a 8600gt would be ok to run on med settings?

  Sj67 16:29 02 Mar 2008

yes 8600gt would run it fine it may even do the higehr settings you can a 8600gt for around £50-£60 from novatech. They have a wide variety.

  Razza14 16:44 02 Mar 2008

Ok thanks. and what do you guys think of dell pc's i was looking at this one:

click here

the one on the left for £329 and i would also upgrade the graphics card on it. Let me know whether it would be ok for games like cod 4?

This thread is now locked and can not be replied to.

Elsewhere on IDG sites

Best Black Friday Deals 2017

How modern book design was influenced by illustrated manuscripts

Best Black Friday Apple Deals 2017

Les meilleurs logiciels de montage vidéo gratuits (en 2017)